5 Situations To Consider Secondary Fermenting

A common question I here a lot from home brewers is, “Do I need to secondary ferment?”.  The answer to this question is a bit complicated and really is a case by case, so as of now I will say, “It depends”.

Before we dive in too deep, I should first clarify for those that don’t know what secondary fermentation is.  Secondary fermentation is when the beer is racked over (siphoned from your primary fermenter into another fermenter) into usually a carboy, acting as a second holding area for your beer, wine, mead etc.  With that said, what do you really gain by secondary fermentation? This is where the, “It depends” comes in.

Here are 5 situations when you might consider putting your beer in a secondary fermenter:  

1) If the beer has a lots of sediment, by putting it in a secondary fermenter you will not have as much sediment in your bottle.  With oatmeal stouts this can be a big plus or a brew that has lots of steeping grains.

2) By putting beer in a secondary fermenter you are allowing your beer to settle and for flavors to blend.  This can be a good idea for Belgians or beers of higher alcohols even IPA’s.  Think about chili or soup, it always taste better on the second day. Why is that that? The flavors have blended together.

3) You can use secondary fermentation to add clarifiers.  Post boil claifers work in secondary fermentation.  I personally use gelatin which helps clarify beers.  If your not kegging your beer’s this is one great way to avoid even more sediment in your bottles.

4) You can ingredients to the secondary.  Dry hopping, oak, spices, all of these work best in the secondary.  I have found with my past brews that when you add any or all of the ingredients listed above into a secondary fermentation you can smell them better.  In my opinion, if you can smell it, you will start to pick up on them even more when you taste them.  So if you are trying to bring out certain flavors, consider what you can do in the secondary.

5) Another reason for secondary fermentation to is if you know you won’t be bottling for a while.  Let’s face it we have things to do other then brewing. A good reason to secondary ferment is that if you make a brew, but you know that you aren’t going to have the time to bottle for a few weeks. In this situation I would recommend you put your beer in a secondary and just let it chill out in there for a while until you can get to bottling.  Rule of thumb for me is: I try not to keep things in primary fermentation for more then 2 weeks.  The reason for this is I’ve found that you can get some off flavors to the beer if left to long in the primary.  

So going back to it all, when would you not want to secondary ferment?  It really depends.  Some beers in my opinion really don’t need it.  If you’ve ever come down to Jay’s Brewing or know me personally, I’m sure that I’ve mentioned how I love sessions brews (Scottish 60L, Milds, Browns anything less then 2.5% -3.9% for me). Typically you don’t need to secondary ferment these.

The reason why is that there is not a lot to them.  I make sessions and will have them pumped out quickly.  Quickly as in a week, then they are bottled (really not that hard to do with such a low alcohol level).  If you are trying to stay away from beers that need secondary fermentation, rule of thumb: Don’t brew stuff that is over 6.8%.  I should emphasize rule of thumb, every one has there own rule on this one – this has worked fine for me.

If you are dead set on the secondary fermentation or think that you need to for the next brew, the question normally is, “What should I secondary ferment in?”.  I would recommend a 5 gallon carboy for secondary fermentation. Now there are 2 different types of carboys: 1) Plastic  2) Glass.

We’ll keep this short because I feel that the discussion of preference between plastic and glass carboy’s deserves its own blog post, which we will do in the coming weeks.  But, you will want a plastic or a glass carboy. If it’s for a 5 gallon batch use a 5 gallon carboy.  The reason why you want to use a carboy is that the top of the carboy goes upwards, so surface area of the brew is reduced which makes it less likely to oxidize.

The make shift way of getting around this is quite easy and something I use to do when I first got started out with brewing – I didn’t want to fork over money for a carboy.  I would take the brew from the primary, rack it over to the bottling bucket, clean out the primary/sanitize, pour the beer back into the primary close it up, then shake it up and your done.

Is that the correct way of doing it? No, but it worked and never had a ruined batch from it.  The main thing that you have to do is, make sure to shake it up a little bit. The reason for shaking up the brew is you need to get CO2 to build a layer over the beer to protect it from O2 oxidizing the beer.  By shaking up the fermenter you are getting they O2 out of the brew threw the air lock.

At the end of it, I try not to get too stressed over secondary fermentation. I do it for my, “gourmet” brews that I pride myself on with being more technical.  On just drinking beers, I don’t. I’m sure people could argue either way, on why you need to do it with every brew and people could argue why not to do it.

If your considering using secondary fermentation, I think you should know why you want to.  If it’s one of the reasons that I listed, consider doing it. If you have any other reasons why you should secondary ferment please let us know.

, , ,

7 Comments on “5 Situations To Consider Secondary Fermenting”

  1. Brendan McCracken Says:

    There’s a large portion of the brewing community that’s moving away from using secondary fermentation. It turns out that the yeast cake starts processing the secondary flavors after it has run out of fermentable sugars. This supposedly makes the beer have a much cleaner taste and finish. Proponents of leaving the beer longer in the primary and avoiding the secondary treat the post-fermentation period of the primary as an unracked secondary and add flavorings and dry-hop at this time. They swear that clarification happens just the same and is more complete because you’re not disturbing the beer. One of my best friends is a long-time brewer who stopped secondary fermenting years ago and now swears by it. He’s been trying to get me to stop using a secondary for about a 6 months now.

    I typically rack everything I brew to secondary but have started leaving my beer in the primary for longer periods of time after my friend started hounding me about the benefits of post-fermentation yeast cake modification. The taste of my beer has noticeably improved, but I’m still using a secondary. My first foray into secondary-free brewing is the batch I currently have in the primary (now in its 2nd week of 3) which is a modified Marzen (non-lagered). I’ll let you know how it turns out.


    • Jay's Brewing Blog Says:

      Ya, I’ve seen the dwindle in people using secondary fermentation as well. And exactly what you are talking about is the fad or the new way of doing things from what I’ve heard from customers. I really don’t have much of an opinion on it. I figure to each is there own. I still do the secondary when I fee I need to and the brews turn out great.

      I’ve made a brew and forgot to get yeast for it before, so what I ended up doing was – bottling a batch that was in the primary then pouring the beer I just made onto that yeast cake that was left in the primary. I’m not sure if your not suppose to do that or not but something that I ended up doing anyways and the beer turned out great. Could have been a lucky shot though, who knows.

      The home brewing world is always having new techniques come and go. I figure what ever works for you, you should do.

      Can’t wait to hear how your marzen turns out, make sure to let me know.





  1. 21 Ways To Keep Passion In The Hobby Of Homebrewing | Jay's Brewing Blog - August 8, 2012

    […] some complicated beers with adding fruit or oak chips, or spices to it.  Or try different brewing techniques, that’s the beauty of this hobby – you can always learn something new and always get […]

  2. Flavorful Spiced Metheglin | Jay's Brewing Blog - January 22, 2013

    […] When To Consider Secondary Fermentaion […]

  3. Mixed Beberry Melomel Recipe | Jay's Brewing Blog - January 23, 2013

    […] 5 Situations To Consider Secondary Fermentation […]

  4. The Best Summer Blonde Ale Recipe | Jay's Brewing Blog - January 24, 2013

    […] When To Consider Secondary Fermentation […]

  5. Tip And Trick To Get A Rubber Stopper Out Of A Carboy… | Jay's Brewing Blog - January 25, 2013

    […] When To Use Secondary […]

Leave a Reply to Jay's Brewing Blog Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: